Delicious Lemon IceBox Pie Recipe (2024)

Published: Jul 21, 2011 · Modified: Apr 29, 2020 by Megan Porta · This post may contain affiliate links.

A concentrated lemon filling plus a graham cracker crust creates the most perfect dessert. This delicious lemon icebox pie is delightful and so delicious. A small chilled slice goes a long way. It’s the perfect summer treat!

I will admit that since starting this blog, I don’t often make the same thing twice. If I do make something more than once, its status automatically becomes Excellent. This lemon pie? EXCELLENT. It is insanely delicious and will be made again and again in my kitchen. My husband and I each took a bite and simultaneously went, “Ohhhh! MMMmmm!” We agreed that it tastes like Key Lime Pie’s first cousin, Key Lemon Pie. And then we fought over the rest of the piece.

HOW TO MAKE LEMON ICEBOX PIE

Graham cracker crumbs wrap around a slightly tart lemon filling that is sure to delight the senses!

STEP 1 – MAKE THE CRUST

Preheat your oven to 325 degrees F.

Add to a food processor:

• 14 whole graham crackers, broken

• 1/4 cup sugar

• 1/4 teaspoon salt

Pulse until finely ground but not powdery. Add 6 tablespoons of butter and pulse until the crumbs are evenly moistened.

STEP 2 – MAKE THE FILLING

Transfer crumbs to a 9-inch springform pan and press into the bottom and two-thirds up the side. Set the pie crust on a rimmed baking sheet.

In a medium mixing bowl, beat together:

• Two 14-oz. cans sweetened condensed milk

• 1 1/4 cups fresh lemon juice

In another bowl, add:

• 2 tablespoons finely grated lemon zest

• 8 large egg yolks

Using a handheld mixer, beat the zest-yolk mixture until pale. Beat in the condensed milk mixture until smooth. Pour the filling into the crust.

STEP 3 – ASSEMBLE THE PIE

Bake the pie in the preheated oven for about 25 minutes, or until the edges are set and the center jiggles slightly when the pie is moved.

Transfer the pan to a rack. Allow it to cool for 1 hour. Loosely cover the pan with plastic wrap and freeze the pie for at least 6 hours or overnight.

SERVE!

Wrap a warm, damp kitchen towel around the side of the springform pan to release the pie and remove the ring. Using a hot knife, slice the pie, transfer to plates and serve immediately.

RECIPE TIPS

• A homemade whipped cream is just the perfect topping to a perfect lemon flavored dessert!

• Feel free to enjoy this both frozen or just refrigerated. The texture firms up a bit and gives it just a little something frozen! Both are great options.

• To make this a simpler recipe, simply purchase a pre-made graham cracker crust.

WHAT IS ZEST

Zesting a fruit simply means to scrape off the outer part of the peeling of the fruit and grate it into a form that brings a lot of concentrated flavor as an ingredient in a recipe. These are often done with unwaxed outer skins of a citrus fruit – lemons, oranges and limes. The zest alone doesn’t taste good but is amazing when incorporated into a recipe.

CAN YOU FREEZE LEMON PIE

Yes! Wrap the container tightly in foil and freeze for up to 4 months. When ready to enjoy, allow it to thaw in the fridge overnight and enjoy!

HOW TO TELL IF A LEMON IS RIPE

I have lemons on hand all the time because we never know when we’ll want to make our favorite citrus co*cktail. Plus its magical juice just goes great in so many recipes. When picking them out at the grocery store, look for these attributes to make sure you are getting the juiciest, ripest ones:

• First, give it a smell. Go ahead, put it right up to your nose and smell for a strong lemony scent. The stronger the scent, the riper the fruit will be.

• The deeper yellow in color they are, the juicier they are, as well.

• The heavier it feels in your hands, the more juice is hiding inside. Gently squeeze it in your hands. The more give it has, the juicier it’ll be. If it is too squishy it may be past its prime, so be sure it doesn’t give too much.

WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ICEBOX PIE AND LEMON MERINGUE?

An icebox pie is tangier because it uses more lemon. Ice box pie uses sweetened condensed milk and lemon meringue is made with a custard filling.

ARE KEY LIME PIE AND LEMON ICEBOX PIE SIMILAR?

They are very similar in their ingredients apart from the fresh lemon juice and fresh key lime juice. Both are delicious!

SALTED BUTTER VS UNSALTED BUTTER

Ahh, the great baking debate. Many bakers use unsalted butter in their baked goods in order to avoid over-salting. I, however, believe that there is no such thing as “over-salting.” I always use salted butter in my baked goods (and for everything else under the sun) because it gives everything I make an extra touch of salty deliciousness. If you go the unsalted route, keep in mind that you may need to add a bit extra salt to the recipe!

OTHER DELICIOUS PIE RECIPES TO TRY

• No Bake Strawberry Pie

• Easy Apple Pie

• Salted Caramel Pie

• Berry Slab Pie

BEST LEMON DESSERT RECIPES

If you or anyone in your life loves lemon desserts as much as I do, consider making one or more of these delicious sugary concoctions:

• Lemon Blueberry Layer Cake with Lemon Buttercream – This Lemon Blueberry Layer Cake with Lemon Buttercream Frosting will knock your socks off, from the blueberry- and lemon-infused cake, through the succulent lemon curd and straight to the lemony buttercream frosting. It’s a show-stopper, both in taste and appearance!

• Lemon Curd – Lemon Curd is a fresh, light and lemony filling or topping that goes great on cakes, cookies, cupcakes or any baked treat!

• Lemon Ball Cookies – Lemon Drops candies inside of cookies = insanely fabulous. Great dessert option for your next holiday baking tray!

• Candied Lemon Slices – Candied Lemon Slices are EASY to make! They make beautiful edible garnishes for baked goods and can be enjoyed as a treat, as well. Such a great way to use up lemons!

• Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake Bars – Simplify cheesecake and pack it full of two delicious types of fruit!